San Francisco's Empty Homes Tax is Permanently Enjoined - What the Ruling Means for California
This is a major win for California's rental housing providers. San Francisco's Empty Homes Tax (Proposition M), also known as a vacancy tax, is now permanently enjoined and cannot be enforced.
On September 11, 2026, the First District Court of Appeal ruled in Debbane v. City and County of San Francisco that the tax is preempted by the state Ellis Act. Because the City did not petition the California Supreme Court for review by the October 21, 2026 deadline, that decision is now final and the injunction is permanent.
The named plaintiffs Eric and Andrew Debbane were joined by individual small property owners, the Small Property Owners of San Francisco Institute (SPOSFI) – an affiliate of the California Rental Housing Association (CalRHA), and a coalition of housing associations in challenging the tax. They prevailed after nearly four years of litigation.
About Proposition M
San Francisco voters approved Proposition M on November 8, 2022, with 54.5% of the vote. The tax was scheduled to take effect on January 1, 2024, with the first filings and payments scheduled for 2025.
It applied to residential units in buildings of three or more units that sat vacant for more than 182 days in a calendar year. The tax started at $2,500 to $5,000 per unit, depending on size, and increased each year a unit stayed vacant, reaching as much as $20,000 per unit by the third year.
The litigation
In February 2023, SPOSFI joined the San Francisco Apartment Association, the San Francisco Association of Realtors, and several individual property owners in suing the City. The named plaintiffs, Eric and Andrew Debbane, live in a five-unit building and keep the remaining units for their own use.
On October 31, 2024, Superior Court Judge Charles Haines ruled for the plaintiffs, finding the tax both unconstitutional and preempted by the Ellis Act. His judgment barred the City from enforcing or administering the tax. The City appealed, and the Board of Supervisors suspended the tax while the appeal moved forward.
The Court of Appeal's reasoning
A unanimous three-justice panel affirmed the trial court on Ellis Act grounds. The Ellis Act (Government Code section 7060 et seq.) bars public entities from compelling residential property owners to offer, or continue to offer, units for rent or lease. The court's key findings:
-
Staying out of the rental market is protected. The City argued that owners could avoid the tax by renting, occupying, or repurposing their units, or by simply paying it. The court disagreed, holding that the Ellis Act protects the right to stay out of the rental business just as much as the right to leave it, and that a city cannot attach a prohibitive price to exercising that right.
-
Alternative uses were not realistic. Converting units into offices, gyms, or studios was not a real option, the court found, since those uses run counter to Prop. M's stated goal of housing people and may not be allowed under the City's planning rules.
-
Calling it a tax did not change the outcome. At oral argument, the City contended that a tax cannot compel anyone to rent. The court found the argument came too late and, in any event, did not alter the Ellis Act analysis.
-
Constitutional claims were left undecided. Because the Ellis Act was enough to resolve the case, the court did not rule on the plaintiffs' takings, privacy, and other constitutional claims.
Implications for other jurisdictions
As a published opinion, Debbane provides a legal precedent that trial courts are likely to follow, and its reasoning applies to local taxes that are designed to push vacant residential units onto the rental market.
-
Berkeley: Measure M (2022), in effect since January 2024, taxes residential units vacant more than 182 days a year, starting at $3,000 per unit and doubling after two years. Because its structure closely mirrors Prop. M, it is the most exposed. The Berkeley Property Owners Association, also a CalRHA affiliate, said earlier this year that it would challenge the tax if the San Francisco ruling were upheld.
-
Oakland: Measure W (2018) taxes vacant residential units, commercial properties, and undeveloped parcels. Its residential provisions may be vulnerable under the same reasoning, though its commercial and vacant-land provisions fall outside the Ellis Act.
-
San Diego: In June 2026, voters rejected Measure A, a proposed $8,000 to $10,000 annual tax on vacant non-primary homes, by roughly 58% to 42%. Opponents pointed to the San Francisco litigation throughout the campaign.
-
Jurisdictions considering a vacancy tax: Any new residential vacancy tax would likely face an Ellis Act challenge, with Debbane as a controlling precedent. Local officials should weigh that legal risk, and the cost of defending such a measure, before moving forward.
The information in this article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or professional advice. Every situation is unique, and laws and regulations may vary based on individual circumstances. Individuals are encouraged to seek advice from a qualified legal professional regarding their specific situation before taking any action.